Thursday, September 27, 2012

Non-Waivable Provisions of Texas LLC Law

Is there a business law topic that doesn't benefit from the input of a quote from a 1980's movie starring Chevy Chase?  I sure hope not!

This blog post will explore the ability of a Texas limited liability company to waive the default provisions under the Texas Limited Liability Company Law (TLLCL) (Title 3 and Title 1, as applicable, of the Texas Business Organizations Code (TBOC)).  So we now turn to Fletch on the importance of waivers:    

Fletch: Aren't you gonna read me my rights?
Cop: You have the right to remain silent. You have the right to have your face kicked in by me. You have the right to have your balls stomped on by him.
Fletch: I think I'll waive my rights.

Generally, the members of a Texas limited liability company are free to agree to virtually any arrangement regarding the management and operation of their limited liability company.  For example, the members may have the same or different management rights, economic (profit and loss) rights, voting rights, information rights, etc.  This flexible nature of the limited liability company structure is part of the reason why the LLC has become the most popular choice of entity in Texas.  But if the members fail to reach an agreement on any of these issues, or if the company agreement of the limited liability company is silent on them, the TLCL provides default provisions which will govern the LLC and its members.  For example, absent an agreement to the contrary, a member of an LLC has no right to withdraw from the company and the other members have no right to expel him (Section 101.107 of the TBOC).  Another default provision under the TLLCL provides that absent an agreement to the contrary, profits and losses of the LLC are allocated among the members in proportion to the agreed value of the members' respective contributions to the company (Section 101.201 of the TBOC).

Fortunately, virtually every default provision of the TLLCL can be modified by agreement of the LLC's members (Section 101.052(c) of the TBOC).  The exceptions to that general rule (i.e., the non-waivable provisions of the TLLCL) are the following matters identified in Section 101.054 of the TBOC:


(1)  Section 101.054 of the TBOC itself may not be waived or modified (obviously!);
(2)  The LLC must have at least one member (Section 101.101 of the TBOC);
(3)  A promise to contribute to the LLC must be in writing and signed to be enforceable (Section 101.151 of the TBOC);
(4)  The LLC may not make distributions if it would cause the LLC's liabilities to exceed the value of its assets.  Similarly, a Series LLC may not make a distribution with respect to any series if its liabilities would exceed its assets. (Sections 101.206 and 101.613 of the TBOC);
(5)  The LLC has an obligation to maintain a list of its members and their respective ownership percentages and other books and records (Section 101.501 of the TBOC);
(6)  If the company is a Series LLC, it must respect the integrity of each series of membership (Section 101.602(b) of the TBOC);
(7)  Words and phrases interpreted or defined in Chapter 1 of the TBOC (Definitions and other General Provisions) may not be waived or modified to the extent such words or phrases are used to interpret a provision or define a word or phrase contained in one of the Sections listed above or below;
(8)  Chapter 2 of the TBOC (Purposes and Powers) may not be waived or modified, except that the following Sections of Chapter 2 may be waived or modified in the company agreement:

  • Section 2.104(c)(2)(permitting a member to challenge a guaranty by the company as not benefiting the   company);
  • Section 2.104(c)(3)(permitting the company or its legal representative to challenge a guaranty as not benefiting the company); or 
  • Section 2.113 (limiting the company's purposes and powers);

(9)  Chapter 3 of the TBOC (Formation and Governance), may not be waived or modified, except that Subchapter C (Governing Persons and Officers) and Subchapter E (Certificates Representing Ownership Interest) may be waived or modified in the company agreement; and
(10)  Chapter 4 of the TBOC (Filings) may not be waived or modified;
(11)  Chapter 5 of the TBOC (Names of Entities, Registered Agents & Registered Offices) may not be waived or modified;
(12)  Chapter 7 of the TBOC (Liability) may not be waived or modified;
(13)  Chapter 10 of the TBOC (Mergers, Interest Exchanges, Conversions & Sales of Assets) may not be waived or modified;
(14)  Chapter 11 of the TBOC (Winding Up & Termination) may not be waived or modified, except that Section 11.056 (requiring a winding up of the company upon the company no longer having members with certain exceptions) may be waived or modified; and
(15)  Chapter 12 of the TBOC (Administrative Powers) may not be waived or modified.

Of course, any provision listed above may be waived or modified in the company agreement if (1) the provision itself authorizes the limited liability company to waive or modify the provision in the company's governing documents, or (2) if the provision itself specifies: (A) the person or group of persons entitled to approve a modification; or (B) the vote or other method by which a modification is required to be approved.

A provision of the TLLCL that grants a right to a person, other than a member, manager, officer, or assignee of a membership interest in a limited liability company, may be waived or modified in the company agreement of the company only if the person consents to the waiver or modification.

Finally, Section 101.054 of the TBOC notes that the company agreement may not unreasonably restrict a person's right of access to records and information under Section 101.502 of the TBOC.

23 comments:

  1. I was wondering if you could expand on 101.054(b)-(c). They seem counter-intuitive to the entirety of section 101.054. If one of the provisions authorizes in the governing documents that it can be waived and/or modified, doesn't that render this subsection of the TBOC obsolete? Any clarification and/or examples would be greatly appreciated!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Additionally legal advisors need to expect that any Internet or non-Internet promoting or publicizing they do may well deliver next to zero outcomes for the measure of time and cash they spend - paying little heed to what an outside showcasing or promoting counselor may state despite what might be expected. Phillips & Assoc

    ReplyDelete
  3. One of the most appealing and bewitching blog that I read recently.
    Joseph Hayon

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your lawyer might be able to get an extension of time from your opponent or the court, or rearrange other matters to accommodate the delay.about me

    ReplyDelete
  5. This blog is a punchy bit of composing, as it has a solid impact.
    Medical Malpractice Lawyers Philadelphia

    ReplyDelete
  6. Man feels the squeeze when the law of wilderness is connected against them and the law of nature is denied to him. עורך דין פלילי

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  8. In the event that you have any therapeutic records identifying with your mischance, make certain to bring duplicates of those for your legal advisor to survey workers compensation attorney philly

    ReplyDelete
  9. These fundamental principles are equality, fraternity, justice and liberty. The Indian constitution, for example, incorporates these goals in the preamble to the constitution which seeks to secure for all its citizens justice, liberty, equality and to promote among them the spirit of fraternity.kurzfeld

    ReplyDelete
  10. Whether you are looking to start a business anywhere in Miami, reorganize an existing business, or simply need advice concerning day-to-day business transactions, you want a law firm or experienced corporate law attorney in Miami who will be able to give you and your corporate legal concerns as much attention and effort as possible. Corporate law attorney understands that in business, time is real money. lemon law lawyers california

    ReplyDelete
  11. Heineken's company profile is centered around a list of the four key factors that make it unique -- most importantly, its global reach, its passionate, diverse team. Riverbrook Animal Hospital

    ReplyDelete
  12. One great reason for allowing the Law of Gratitude to flow in your life is because it will promotes endorphin chemicals to be released within the body affecting every cell promoting feelings of optimism, relaxation and happiness. commercial lawyers pakistan

    ReplyDelete
  13. Another approach is metric based procedure which can be figured in light of the business metric being viewed as like deals system, development methodology and so on.list of nonprofits

    ReplyDelete
  14. Every thing in such societies appears to be in order. The roads are clean, lawns and parks are well-maintained, government officials work in office, trains and public transports run on time. Attorney at Law

    ReplyDelete
  15. North Texas! Some indepth information about these provisions.
    read this

    ReplyDelete
  16. After gathering another or imminent customer and trading business cards, the customer will get an impression of your firm in view of the law firm logo alone. trademark registration

    ReplyDelete
  17. A decent and capable driver is somebody who takes after the traffic laws and directions.Read about drunken driving

    ReplyDelete
  18. If driver is not careful or under the influence alcohol or banned drugs, if the weather conditions are unclear or vehicle parts are faulty etc, are some of the common ones. Detroit Auto Accident Lawyer

    ReplyDelete
  19. I went over this website and I conceive you've got a large number of splendid information, http://www.folgerlaw.com

    ReplyDelete
  20. thanks for this usefull article, waiting for this article like this again.
    עורךדיןתעבורה

    ReplyDelete
  21. Little firms and new organizations are typically shy of assets and assets to have an in-house legitimate group.Free classified site

    ReplyDelete
  22. Green juices are made with fruits and vegetables filled with antioxidants, phytochemicals, minerals and vitamins Workers compensation attorney

    ReplyDelete
  23. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete